Publication detail
Comparison of Modal Parameter Estimation Techniques For Experimental Modal Analysis
ONDRA, V. LOŠÁK, P.
Czech title
Porovnání metod pro získání modálních parametrů při experimentální modální analýze
English title
Comparison of Modal Parameter Estimation Techniques For Experimental Modal Analysis
Type
conference paper
Language
en
Original abstract
This paper deals with comparison of three commonly used modal parameter estimation methods (Pick Picking, Least Square Complex Exponential and Eigensystem Realization Algorithm) in order to judge about their accuracy and limitation. There have been invented a great amount of modal parameter estimation techniques in the field of experimental modal analysis. However, there is not universal method which would be suitable for every possible structure and/or with acceptable accuracy. As a test structure, 15 degrees of freedom plane with given mass, damping and stiffness was chosen. The foundations of discussed methods are described, their implementation on the test structure is shown and finally, natural frequencies and damping obtained by analytical approach are compared with those estimated using mentioned techniques. In addition, mode shapes differences are illustrated by means of Modal Assurance Criterion. Based on these comparisons, an accuracy and limitation of the methods is summarized in the conclusion.
Czech abstract
Tato práce se zabývá srovnáním tří běžně používaných metod pro odhad modálních parametrů (Pick Picking, Least Square Complex Exponential a Eigensystem Realization Algorithm). Cílem bylo posoudit a ověřit jejich přesnost a omezení. Existuje mnoho metod pro stanovení modálních parametrů, avšak žádná není univerzální, která by byla vhodná pro všechny systémy s přijatelnou přesností. V tomto příspěvku byl použit jako tesovací struktura model desky s 15 stupni volnosti s definovaným tlumením a tuhosti. Pomocí jednotlivých metod byly získány vlastní frekvence a tlumení systému. Přesnosti a omezení jednotlivých metod jsou shrnuty v závěru.
English abstract
This paper deals with comparison of three commonly used modal parameter estimation methods (Pick Picking, Least Square Complex Exponential and Eigensystem Realization Algorithm) in order to judge about their accuracy and limitation. There have been invented a great amount of modal parameter estimation techniques in the field of experimental modal analysis. However, there is not universal method which would be suitable for every possible structure and/or with acceptable accuracy. As a test structure, 15 degrees of freedom plane with given mass, damping and stiffness was chosen. The foundations of discussed methods are described, their implementation on the test structure is shown and finally, natural frequencies and damping obtained by analytical approach are compared with those estimated using mentioned techniques. In addition, mode shapes differences are illustrated by means of Modal Assurance Criterion. Based on these comparisons, an accuracy and limitation of the methods is summarized in the conclusion.
Keywords in Czech
Experimentální modální analýza, určení modálních parametrů, modal assurance.
Keywords in English
Experimental Modal Analysis, Modal Parameter Estimation, Modal Assurance Criterion
RIV year
2014
Released
12.05.2014
ISBN
978-80-214-4871-1
Book
ENGINEERING MECHANICS 2014
Edition number
2014
Pages from–to
460–463
Pages count
762
BIBTEX
@inproceedings{BUT108006,
author="Václav {Ondra} and Petr {Lošák},
title="Comparison of Modal Parameter Estimation Techniques For Experimental Modal Analysis",
booktitle="ENGINEERING MECHANICS 2014",
year="2014",
month="May",
pages="460--463",
isbn="978-80-214-4871-1"
}